How to Make the Most of Fall: An NYC Fall Bucket List

With the chill in the air, it’s finally beginning to feel like autumn in NYC! It’s tempting to take one long look at the leaves changing colors and then huddle in my room for the next six months but there’s so much more to autumn than that. So in the spirit of having one last hurrah before winter, I’ve put together a bucket list of my top things to do to make the most of fall in NYC.

Spend the day at City Island

This is usually considered a summertime thing to do, but if there’s anything more charming than a New England-esque fishing village in the summer, it’s a New England-esque fishing village in the autumn. The ideal afternoon would be strolling down the mile-long island, checking out everything from the classic Victorian houses to the dreamy Long Island Sound. When you’re done, dine at any one of the myriad seafood joints. I hear Sammy’s Fish Box is a local favorite.

Marvel at architectural wonders during Open House New York Weekend

Open House New York is the one weekend a year where the beautiful, but usually off-limits, buildings we walk by on the daily are opened up, so we, the masses, can gaze upon their glamor. On my must-see list this year: the Andrew Freedman Home, a Renaissance-style palazzo built as a retirement home for the formerly wealthy; the Hall of Fame of Great Americans at Bronx Community College; inside the Prison Ship Martyrs Monument in Brooklyn’s Fort Greene Park; the Mount Vernon Hotel Museum & Garden in Manhattan; and the Hindu Temple Society of North America in Queens. Note: OHNY 2019 takes place from October 18-20.

Take Madame Morbid’s Trolley Tour

This is something I did a couple of years back, but it was so much fun that I have to do it again. If a vintage trolley car and eerie stories of local murder and mayhem told by a Victorian-era guide don’t get you into the spooky spirit, then nothing will. Madame Morbid’s Trolley Tour mixes macabre with humor as you drive around Brooklyn’s creepiest sites. Prepare yourself to be thoroughly amused.

▢  Visit a rooftop farm

Autumn is the season for farms to shine, but since I can’t make it out to the traditional farms of New Jersey or New England, I’ll get my harvest on NYC-style, at a rooftop farm. Brooklyn Grange has been the go-to place to experience rooftop farming, but I’m also intrigued by Gotham Greens in Gowanus and Eagle Street Farm, which may or may not be the OG of NYC rooftop farms.

Find the best apple cider donuts in the city

While some people go pumpkin-spice-crazy during the fall, I jump off the deep end for apple cider donuts, so it bothers me to no end that these donuts aren’t typically found at bakeries around the city. So far I’ve been pacified with Trader Joe’s apple cider donuts, but if you know of anywhere else that sells them, pass that knowledge on!

Pose with a pumpkin at New York Botanical Garden’s Giant Pumpkin Weekend

NYBG is not joking when they call this Giant Pumpkin Weekend. Last year they brought in a gourd that weighed more than 2,500 pounds. (Imagine how many pumpkin pies you could make with that?) Even if this year’s pumpkin was half that size, it would still be worth seeing in the flesh. Check it out October 26-27, 2019.

Step foot into one of NYC’s supposedly haunted houses

Confession time: I scare easily. I don’t like thinking about ghosts. I don’t like talking about ghosts. Heck, I even avoid reading history books at night so I don’t come across any of those black and white photos from the late 1800s where people only knew how to give menacing looks that pierce deep into your soul. So if there’s one thing on this list that’ll require real effort to accomplish, it’s this. Luckily, or perhaps unluckily for me, there’s no shortage of potential haunted places in NYC. For starters, there’s the Merchant’s House Museum, Renwick Smallpox Hospital, St. Mark’s Church in-the-Bowery, and the Morris-Jumel Mansion (I’d list more but I’m already too creeped out). Visit at your own risk.

Spend the day in Green-Wood Cemetery

For a person who squirms at the mention of ghosts, it seems strange that I’d want to spend the day at a cemetery, but Green-Wood Cemetery isn’t your run-of-mill cemetery. When it opened in 1838, New Yorkers took to it as a kind of park, strolling through it, admiring the view from Battle Hill, and picnicking. I reckon that today it’s still just as pleasant a place to spend an afternoon, and with all the fall foliage, it might be one of the best leaf peeping spots in the city.

What’s on your list of things to do during this NYC fall? Any recommendations on where I can find a decent apple cider donut? Let me know in the comments!

NYC Fall Bucket List Pinterest

Tell me what you think!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.